The High Court has reinforced the importance of properly assessing insight and remediation in fitness to practise proceedings, while highlighting why these factors must be considered alongside the seriousness of misconduct and the wider public interest.
In Professional Standards Authority for Health and Social Care v Health and Care Professions Council & Anor [2026] EWHC 2926 (Admin), the court overturned a four-year caution imposed on an occupational therapist following serious and repeated dishonesty. Although the registrant had demonstrated insight and undertaken extensive remediation, the High Court concluded that these mitigating factors did not justify the sanction imposed.
The judgement provides an important reminder for doctors and other healthcare professionals facing fitness to practise investigations: demonstrating insight and remediation is critical, but it is equally important to ensure that the evidence is properly developed, presented and supported by an effective legal defence strategy.
The case: insight and remediation were not enough to justify a caution
The case concerned an occupational therapist who had fabricated employment references, misrepresented his professional registration history and provided false information to secure employment as a disability assessor.
The HCPC’s Conduct and Competence Committee found his fitness to practise impaired by reason of misconduct. It recognised the seriousness of the dishonesty but also considered several mitigating factors, including the registrant’s insight, reflection and extensive and appropriate remediation.
The committee concluded that the risk of repetition was low and imposed a four-year caution rather than suspension.
However, the Professional Standards Authority challenged the decision. The High Court allowed the appeal, finding that the committee had incorrectly characterised the misconduct as isolated and had failed to provide adequate reasons for concluding that a caution was sufficient.
Importantly, the judge did not dismiss the registrant’s insight or remediation. Indeed, the judgement expressly acknowledged the significant mitigation available to him. However, the seriousness of the misconduct, considered alongside the applicable sanctions guidance and the need to maintain public confidence, meant that suspension was the appropriate sanction.
The court’s decision demonstrates an important distinction: insight and remediation can significantly influence the assessment of impairment and sanction, but they do not automatically determine the outcome of a fitness to practise case.
Insight and remediation: demonstrating change, not simply expressing regret
For healthcare professionals facing fitness to practise proceedings, insight and remediation are often central to the defence.
However, there is a considerable difference between saying that you understand what went wrong and demonstrating that understanding to a regulatory panel.
Insight requires meaningful reflection on the underlying conduct, the circumstances in which it occurred, the impact on others and the professional standards expected. It also involves recognising personal vulnerabilities, understanding why the behaviour was inappropriate and demonstrating how those lessons have influenced subsequent decisions and professional practice.
Remediation goes further. It requires evidence of the steps taken to address the concerns, the learning achieved and, importantly, how that learning has been translated into sustained changes in behaviour and practice.
Simply attending courses, completing reflective statements or expressing regret will not necessarily satisfy a regulatory panel. The evidence needs to be relevant to the allegations, demonstrate genuine learning and show how the risk of similar concerns arising in the future has been addressed.
This is particularly important in cases involving dishonesty, probity, professional boundaries, clinical competence and attitudinal concerns, where demonstrating meaningful and sustained change can be challenging.
The High Court has reinforced the importance of properly assessing insight and remediation in fitness to practise proceedings, while highlighting why these factors must be considered alongside the seriousness of misconduct and the wider public interest.
In Professional Standards Authority for Health and Social Care v Health and Care Professions Council & Anor [2026] EWHC 2926 (Admin), the court overturned a four-year caution imposed on an occupational therapist following serious and repeated dishonesty. Although the registrant had demonstrated insight and undertaken extensive remediation, the High Court concluded that these mitigating factors did not justify the sanction imposed.
The judgement provides an important reminder for doctors and other healthcare professionals facing fitness to practise investigations: demonstrating insight and remediation is critical, but it is equally important to ensure that the evidence is properly developed, presented and supported by an effective legal defence strategy.
The case: insight and remediation were not enough to justify a caution
The case concerned an occupational therapist who had fabricated employment references, misrepresented his professional registration history and provided false information to secure employment as a disability assessor.
The HCPC’s Conduct and Competence Committee found his fitness to practise impaired by reason of misconduct. It recognised the seriousness of the dishonesty but also considered several mitigating factors, including the registrant’s insight, reflection and extensive and appropriate remediation.
The committee concluded that the risk of repetition was low and imposed a four-year caution rather than suspension.
However, the Professional Standards Authority challenged the decision. The High Court allowed the appeal, finding that the committee had incorrectly characterised the misconduct as isolated and had failed to provide adequate reasons for concluding that a caution was sufficient.
Importantly, the judge did not dismiss the registrant’s insight or remediation. Indeed, the judgement expressly acknowledged the significant mitigation available to him. However, the seriousness of the misconduct, considered alongside the applicable sanctions guidance and the need to maintain public confidence, meant that suspension was the appropriate sanction.
The court’s decision demonstrates an important distinction: insight and remediation can significantly influence the assessment of impairment and sanction, but they do not automatically determine the outcome of a fitness to practise case.
Insight and remediation: demonstrating change, not simply expressing regret
For healthcare professionals facing fitness to practise proceedings, insight and remediation are often central to the defence.
However, there is a considerable difference between saying that you understand what went wrong and demonstrating that understanding to a regulatory panel.
Insight requires meaningful reflection on the underlying conduct, the circumstances in which it occurred, the impact on others and the professional standards expected. It also involves recognising personal vulnerabilities, understanding why the behaviour was inappropriate and demonstrating how those lessons have influenced subsequent decisions and professional practice.
Remediation goes further. It requires evidence of the steps taken to address the concerns, the learning achieved and, importantly, how that learning has been translated into sustained changes in behaviour and practice.
Simply attending courses, completing reflective statements or expressing regret will not necessarily satisfy a regulatory panel. The evidence needs to be relevant to the allegations, demonstrate genuine learning and show how the risk of similar concerns arising in the future has been addressed.
This is particularly important in cases involving dishonesty, probity, professional boundaries, clinical competence and attitudinal concerns, where demonstrating meaningful and sustained change can be challenging.
Disclaimer: This article is for guidance purposes only. Kings View Chambers accepts no responsibility or liability whatsoever for any action taken, or not taken, in relation to this article. You should seek the appropriate legal advice having regard to your own particular circumstances.